2012 Lineup

[chriseede]

Who are The Stone Roses? LOL

[pink_triangle]

If you have chosen not to see all 3 of those in the last few years on this basis, you have seriously missed out.

[thetime]

I suppose it depends if you have seen them before, I have never seen a band who were better during a reunion than they were orginally. If you missed them first time round than a reunion is good.

[SpecialAgentKit]

i'm buzzing for billy talent now

[thetime]

Sorry couldnt resist...watching the bestival show for about the 50th time.

[rivalschools.price]

I suppose it depends if you have seen them before, I have never seen a band who were better during a reunion than they were orginally. If you missed them first time round than a reunion is good.

[KingOfTheRodeo]

Youtube video fail

Edited March 18, 2012 by KingOfTheRodeo

[mrtourette]

No need for the sarcasm, I've been going to Leeds for years and know exactly what the festival is about.

So you think BBC are far too high at R/L, but at T they are low because of the festival's pop base? Not because their lineup is stronger?

[FortMorris]

Met Lower Than Atlantis at Takedown festival yesterday. Asked them if they will be at R&L and I got a maybe with a cheeky wink. That's either a confirmation, or he really liked me..

[guitarbhoy1888]

turbonegro announced for download

any chance ?

[rivalschools.price]

turbonegro announced for download

any chance ?

[alex28]

Met Lower Than Atlantis at Takedown festival yesterday. Asked them if they will be at R&L and I got a maybe with a cheeky wink. That's either a confirmation, or he really liked me..

[Andre91]

The Stone Roses are the single most important British band since The Beatles. Frank Gallagher said it on Shameless, it must be true joking aside, I think they are easily in the Top 5 British bands of all time in terms of impact and influence.

[thetime]

The Stone Roses are the single most important British band since The Beatles. I think they are easily in the Top 5 British bands of all time in terms of impact and influence.

[mrtourette]

Not one of these stupid arguments than can never be proven again...

[thetime]

Not one of these stupid arguments than can never be proven again...

Edited March 20, 2012 by thetime

[mrtourette]

I think we can prove the list above have had more impact than a band who were one great album wonders.

Edited March 20, 2012 by mrtourette

[TYLER_4]

The Stone Roses are the single most important British band since The Beatles. Frank Gallagher said it on Shameless, it must be true joking aside, I think they are easily in the Top 5 British bands of all time in terms of impact and influence.

[thetime]

You can prove it? Go for it.

[mrtourette]

It's an interesting argument but it would never have a definitive or proven answer as it would always depend on those involved. The same argument with different people could produce wildly different results.

[Andre91]

Beatles

Rolling stones

Pink floyd

Radiohead

Zepplin

Black sabbath

Sex pistols

The smiths

The cure

Joy division

Oasis

Of the top of my head, do you know what your talking about? Were you around in the late 80s/early 90s.

[thetime]

I obviously don't :L I was just saying what i thought, which I now except as being wrong, no need to get arsey about it really. The Stone Roses are above Oasis though. Oasis are one of my favourite bands ever, but The Beatles + The Stone Roses=Oasis :L just kidding. But even Liam said that without going to see The Stone Roses he wouldnt have been in a band.

[mrtourette]

I think you could make the argument that Oasis were just as influential and had just as much of an impact as The Stone Roses, if not more. It's not a particularly pleasant thing to consider and it's galling given that without the Roses there'd be no Oasis, but that doesn't mean it isn't true.

[Andre91]

Oh I agree that Oasis have been a massive influence, but I'm just saying that they wouldnt have even existed if it wasn't for The Roses. I love both bands, but Oasis more so.

[micawber]

Beatles

Rolling stones

Pink floyd

Radiohead

Zepplin

Black sabbath

Sex pistols

The smiths

The cure

Joy division

Oasis

Of the top of my head, do you know what your talking about? Were you around in the late 80s/early 90s.