Pink Floyd

[Tugger2k]

FFS!!!!!!!!!!!!! Gilmour is by far the heart of the Floyd sound! Except possibly Wright, but still, Gilmour is, for me, pink floyd. Tbh none of them are good without the other!

[Buzlightyear]

FFS!!! he wasnt even IN the band to start with!! how can a f**king session musician define a bands sound??

syd, then rog - without the writers there is no band!!

'on an island' - 'up your own arse' more like!!

[DaveMac]

Couldn't agree more....

[ICGenie]

Give me Gilmour's beautiful, melodic guitar over Rog's caterwauling any day

[DaveMac]

Give me Gilmour's beautiful, melodic guitar over Rog's caterwauling any day

[Triton]

FFS!!! he wasnt even IN the band to start with!! how can a f**king session musician define a bands sound??

[medzy]

Don't know why a few people are getting irate on here..... Pink Floyd is my all time favourite band.

I was too young to see them but have every album and tend to prefer Gilmours songs. Pink Floyd are no more, you may get a Waters (Walters for some of you on here....) or Gilmour set but not together.

Did you see a Division Bell postage stamp from the Royal Mail is coming out the beginning of next year!

[scorp]

i'm pretty sure it rained during Roger Waters set in 2002. everyone in my pictures in wearing jackets/macs with the hood up or hats on

it was an unbelievable set he did though, probably my best ever glastonbury moment. I remember him and the band sitting down to play cards halfway through the set

Pink Floyd can't ever play, but hopefully Waters, Gilmour and Mason will reform for 2010

[grumpyhack]

I remember seeing PF do the first ever live performance of Atom Heart Mother at Shepton Mallet in 69 and would be knocked out to see any of them back at Glasto again.

The Beatles evolved over the years. Although most songs were credited to Lennon and McCartney they wrote most of their material separately. The same was true of PF so I don't think a Gilmore v Waters argument is relevant.

[GlastoEls]

Although most songs were credited to Lennon and McCartney they wrote most of their material separately. The same was true of PF so I don't think a Gilmore v Waters argument is relevant.

[alframsey]

FFS!!! he wasnt even IN the band to start with!! how can a f**king session musician define a bands sound??

syd, then rog - without the writers there is no band!!

'on an island' - 'up your own arse' more like!!

[alframsey]

Give me Gilmour's beautiful, melodic guitar over Rog's caterwauling any day

[Langdale Wolf]

P.s. to call David a session musician is absolutely ludicrous! It's like calling Michael Jackson an averagely good showman, simply not true...

[alframsey]

To be honest, Jackson isn't as good as he used to be these days.

[Mr Ploppy]

FFS!!! he wasnt even IN the band to start with!! how can a f**king session musician define a bands sound??

syd, then rog - without the writers there is no band!!

'on an island' - 'up your own arse' more like!!

[rexclark]

I'd love to see any version of them. I am not a big fan but I lovbe Wish You Were Here and would love to hear it live.

[VCK]

Meh, never got into Pink Floyd though I guess they'd be worth a watch.

[MEGABOWL]

Meh, never got into Pink Floyd though I guess they'd be worth a watch.

[ICGenie]

See!!! Waters was fantastic as well!!! They all brought something to the band, and without either one it wouldn't have been the same. While David may be my personal fave, i realise what the rest brought to the band, and I realise that Gilmour alone couldnt have done it all...

[GlastoEls]

To sum up with the old Floyd cliche - Roger made you think and Dave made you enjoy it.

[Phunkyapple]

Pink Floyd additional members??

[GlastoEls]

Pink Floyd additional members??

[Phunkyapple]

still getting the hang of this link milarky. Pink Fraud, check them out on you tube and their website. Saw them at Glastonbudget and they could fill some gaps...........................??

[sifi]

- Waters is a genius and an incedible songwriter - Amused To Death contains some of the best lyrics ever written.

[Buzlightyear]

I find some of his stuff just too angsty. You know, Thatcher, it's no fair blah-de-blah.

Compared to some bloke called Zimmerman, well, it's like comparing a leader in the Guardian to Shelley.