Jump to content

Don't Miss a Beat

Join the UK's most passionate festival community. Keep up with the latest conversations, line-up rumours, and music news.

250,000+ Members

Connect with a massive network of fellow festival-goers.

Lively Discussions

Thousands of active topics on music, campsites, and tips.

Hot Rumours & News

Hear about secret sets and lineup drops before anyone else.

Create Free Account
OR
  • Sign Up!

    Join our friendly community of music lovers and be part of the fun 😎

Football 2011-2012


Guest eFestivals

Recommended Posts

He asked to go. We tried to keep him that summer but he wanted off. Four seasons out of a Spaniard was a decent return and we sold him for £30m.

He was put off a bit when we tried to sell him a season earlier but then he had been poor the year before, then he had a great season and wanted to go.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 8.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • eFestivals

    1469

  • The Nal

    1095

  • kaosmark2

    1095

  • strummer77

    896

  • Admin

Yet! Give Jones, Smalling, Hernandez, Cleverly, De Gea and Welbeck another two years (they'll all still be under 24) and see where the team is then.

Some at least will be spread around other clubs I reckon.

Fergie seems to have lost confidence in De Gea, so I'm not sure I see him sticking around. He might, but I think it's more likely now that he'll go than stay.

And with the emergence of Welbeck, I'm not sure that you'll have Hernandez for too much longer either. He's young, and he'll want to play more than he's getting opportunities.

With both I'm not saying they're not capable of being at Utd's standard, but I'm not sure they'll still be there two seasons from now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well done liverpool! Carling cup is an important trophy to win(if they do)

Remember thats how mourinho chelsea started winning trophies, and if I remember right uniteds current succes after 3 lean years of chelsea putting down a marker.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Might get to quoting in a bit but on the topic of Spurs vs Liverpool spending:

http://www.transferl...-transfers.html

http://www.transferl...-transfers.html

There isn't a huge deal in it but whatever time period you go for Liverpool out do Spurs for net spend and total spend. Aquianni really hurts their figures I think, along with Downing, Henderson and Keane. Guess you could argue the bulk of Liverpools big spends were more recent so it might take more time to settle in and stuff. Spur made 4th the season after spending around £100m so I guess there's no excuses from Liverpool next season.

As for wages, I don't think you can really ignore how much less Spurs spent. I cba dragging up fiscal reports so am just going off what I remember / just googled now, but (Please correct me if I'm wrong) VDV is Spurs highest at £70k p/w. Torres was much higher then that, but was still less then Gerrard (might of been before a new contract though.) Ol Joey Cole went to L'pool over Spurs due to better wage offer.

Quick google gave me some list of the 'top 100 most paid soccer players'. A quick Ctrl + F shows 5 Liverpool players to 0 Spurs... could easily be more below that too.

http://www.eurosoccerfans.com/top-100-highest-paid-soccer-players/

Edited by jammy2211
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Admin

Might get to quoting in a bit but on the topic of Spurs vs Liverpool spending:

http://www.transferl...-transfers.html

http://www.transferl...-transfers.html

There isn't a huge deal in it but whatever time period you go for Liverpool out do Spurs for net spend and total spend.

Hmmmm .... we've had this discussion here before (which is what I was going from).

It was a few years ago now so the most recent years can be taken out of things, but the transfer lists we worked off at that point showed Spurs net-outspending Liverpool since around 2000 by quite a significant amount, and if I'm remembering rightly it was for every year (tho I might be wrong about that).

Soi perhaps it depends which listing you work from for which answer you get.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmmmm .... we've had this discussion here before (which is what I was going from).

It was a few years ago now so the most recent years can be taken out of things, but the transfer lists we worked off at that point showed Spurs net-outspending Liverpool since around 2000 by quite a significant amount, and if I'm remembering rightly it was for every year (tho I might be wrong about that).

Soi perhaps it depends which listing you work from for which answer you get.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Admin

I would imagine it's because if you take out the years that Liverpool spent the most and Spurs recouped a load (i.e. the recent years) then Spurs might come out on top. Going from 2005 - 2010 Spur's net spend is around £25m higher, but on a much lower wage bill. Going back to 2000 makes the net spends even closer...

However if you take the figure from today to any date in the past 10 years (Probably more) you'll work out Liverpool have spent more cash and 'net spend' then spurs.... with a higher wage bill.

Whatever you do, theres no way you can say Spurs have outspent Liverpool in recent years, certainly not this century.

the wage bills weren't part of what we looked at previously, just the net transfer fees.

I'd say the difference between what you've presented and what we looked at before here is a difference in the lists we've each worked from (there's no way I can remember which list it was previously). Lists like these are often inaccurate, if for no other reason than sometimes the fees aren't disclosed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the wage bills weren't part of what we looked at previously, just the net transfer fees.

I'd say the difference between what you've presented and what we looked at before here is a difference in the lists we've each worked from (there's no way I can remember which list it was previously). Lists like these are often inaccurate, if for no other reason than sometimes the fees aren't disclosed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Surely the most accurate is looking at the cashflow per the accounts.

I don't have Spurs figures, but in comparison to United, Liverpool have spent more over the past decade both gross and net, so I'd be surprised if spent more than Spurs over a decade period, when Spurs didn't have champions league money to help fund.

(in '000s)

Liverpool between the financial years ending '00 to '10, Liverpool spent £402,694 gross, recouped £207,283 for net £195,411.

For the financial years ending '05-'10 (Benitez), they spent £301,120 gross, recouped £144,742 for net £156,378.

In comparison to United:

05-10

Liverpool - £301,120 gross, recouped £144,742 for net £156,378

United - £230,895 gross, recouped £177,501 for net £53,394

00-10

Liverpool - £402,694 gross, recouped £207,283 for net £195,411.

United - £387,831 gross, recouped £224,530, for net £163,301.

Year by Year breakdown

https://docs.google....&hl=en_US#gid=0

prtscns of Liverpool showing back to '04, courtesy of Andersred. He didn't provide further than that, but I wouldn't doubt his veracity. (easy to disprove if false, and wouldn't want credibility impinged).

https://docs.google....wZDIyOTRl&hl=en

(looking for payments to acquire intangible fixed assets, and proceeds from sale of intangible fixed assets.)

prtscns of United last 10 years/

http://andersred.blo...parliament.html

Wages, Spurs have paid far less.

15%2BTottenham%2BWages%2BLeague.jpg

http://swissramble.b...ptimism-or.html

Edited by ralph250
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Admittedly there was a BIG difference in net spends this year which evens it up somewhat, but then that isn't including the fairly unique situation of the Adebayor loan which is a £20m player for free. Full credit for them getting him but you don't often get payers of that value thrown at you for for nothing. However they're either going to have to buy him or buy someone of the equivalent standard to keep them at the same level as this year- and that is going to cost them £20m+. They're only delaying spending that money.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The fact remains that Liverpool are more than capable of holding their own - and better - with the 'big' teams above them. That gets to prove that it's only really with their league position they're failing right now, rather than with who they've bought. The points they've dropped have been almost all against teams they're easily capable of beating as proven by their results against the teams above them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Or using that free loan as a way to get back into the Champs Lge and get ~£35mn. Particularly as they're only paying 1/3 of his wages. Spend £20mn on a striker next summer, net gain ~£15mn. If they don't get back into the Champs Lge, or he has a sulk and goes off form (as he usually does, albeit about 18 months after joining a club), then they're not screwed over.

Edited by strummer77
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Another key point when discussing liverpool in the transfer market, Fergie has a lot easier job than kenny. Fergie bascially has his pick of players that real and barca dont want. Kenny has to pick the best from the players that teams like man u dont want which makes it a lot more challenging. 25 years ago phil jones would probably have ended up at liverpool,, however football is cyclical and the gap between man u and liverpool in the long term will decrease, particualarly when ferige goes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah but I mean they'll still have to buy that striker eventually. It's just a delayed outlay. They are playing the system very well and I don't blame them, but I don't think the system should allow senior players to be loaned from one club to another in the same division. U21s maybe, like Wenger says. My opinion though I suppose!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Admin

Your quote however is "without spending the sums that City, Spurs and Chelski have to reach those heights.".

Wage bills include spending.

you might choose to interpret my words in that way, but that very definitely wasn't what I was meaning.

And clearly, no matter how you twist the figures there is no way Liverpool arn't Spending more then Spurs... different lists will give different figures and whatnot, but non will lead you to any other conclusion.

as others here might remember from that previous discussion, we've certainly compared Liverpool's and Spuirs spending here before and at that time the listings we'd used showed Spurs spending more.

Until that previous discussion I was of the belief that Liverpool would have spent much more, but that certainly wasn't the case with the listings we used at that time.

While your list might be the more accurate of the two, it might not be either. Neither of us has any real way of knowing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Admin

Also the defence was pretty poor last season but pretty good this one, I think with players like johnson there are no guarantees the form will continue.

Johnson isn't a worry. If his form drops then he'll be dropped and replaced by the already-better Kelly.

There might be places to worry about whether Liverpool can maintain their form to date, but Johnson isn't one of them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Latest Activity

    • Very nice to read your review.  Here's mine.  I enjoyed it all so much that I bought a pre-sale ticket for 2027!   ____   WOMAD FESTIVAL 23-26 July 2026  Neston Park, Corsham, Wiltshere   Womad is back! The festival took a year off last year to recalibrate. They were moving to a new location, and no doubt the fact that so many festivals have ceased to exist as a result of financial problems in the current climate made it important for Womad to get things right going forward. And did they! The festival was a resounding success. Sold out, with brilliant music and smiling faces all around.    From 2007 until 2024 the festival was held at Charlton Park in Wiltshere. I went there six times.  Sometimes the festival clashed wth Cambridge Folk Festival, but since the pandemic I have found myself preferring Womad. It offers greater diversity. There are acts from all over the world and I feel I can trust the organisers to come up with stuff I will enjoy.    The new site is a beauty. Neston Park is an estate near Corsham.  Melksham is the nearest train station; Bath the nearest bigger town. The Real World studios are nearby in the village of Box. The weather was again very warm and the site thankfully has many shaded areas with trees. The camping fields offer enough space that people do not need to camp on top of each other. There are four main stages and best of all, programming is such that there was never any sound overspill. Toilets were mostly of the compost variety. The food I sampled was delicious, albeit expensive, and they had very nice Clear Head alcohol-free beer on tap, which predictably ran out on Saturday.    I went as an Oxfam volunteer, which benefits a good cause and was enjoyable as ever, but I have to admit that it was killing me how much I was missing that I wanted to be at, due to having to work. I was not able to participate in the many interesting workshops and presentations on offer. I am planning to go as a punter next year, and volunteer elsewhere where the lineup is less crucial. My shifts were in the camping fields. This was relatively easy due to the Womad festival goers being very well behaved (“You can’t go that way“; “Oh, I see”). I enjoyed spending time up on the fire tower, from where the view was great.   Peter Gabriel made an appearance at the World of Words stage. Lopa Kothari was on compere duty on the World Stage (the main stage), and for me a most welcome addition was Justin Adams compering the second stage - the Big Top. Justin is a fantastic guitarist who has collaborated with and produced many world music greats (Robert Plant, Tinariwen, Souad Massi, Sharon Shannon). Justin is so knowledgeable and enthusiastic, it was a real joy to have him in the Big Top all weekend, and I liked his unshouty style of presenting.   These were my musical highlights:   1. GANAVYA (India) - Big Top   Singer Ganavya is from New York, of Indian heritage, and she spent many years living in Tamil Nadu. The first striking thing when she walks onstage is how pregnant she is. She explains she is eight months. At times it looked like there might be a Womad baby. Ganavya is accompanied by a harpist and a cellist. Stunning music and great storytelling too. She is a graduate from Berklee College of Music and has worked as a teacher as well, which is evident from her engaging talk. She reminded me of Arooj Aftab, mostly because of her dry and self-deprecating sense of humour. Her show ended with a wonderful singalong traditional, the high point of the entire festival for me. I will certainly seek her music out further.   2. SEPPUKU PISTOLS (Japan) - World Stage   The Seppuku Pistols are an anarchist punk group with traditional instruments. There’s thirteen of them, different ages. They started in the middle of the crowd and then made their way over to the stage. Many of the members play percussion. The leader is an older guy, who spoke at length and with great conviction in Japanese, before yelling “translate!” to a band member. There was so much going on, sometimes you didn’t know where to look. I was near the front, but band members frequently went with instruments and all into the moshpit. At the same time someone could come crowdsurfing overhead. Apparently one of them broke his ankle, didn’t realise and finished the gig. “I think you all need to go and decompress”, Lopa Kothari said to the audience once it was over. Everybody left the main stage with big smiles, shaking their heads.   3. GANNA (Ukraine) - Sunflower Tent   Ganna is a Ukrainian singer, based in Berlin. She performs solo, standing behind a table with equipment. This is never my favourite set-up, however her voice, songs, stage presence and stories were so remarkable that I can get over the lack of a proper band. My shift partner saw her at the ‘Taste the World’ stage and told me she is equally good without the box of tricks. Her singing is not unlike Sámi joiking. Ganna’s singing was so impressive that everyone (finally!) stopped talking. Her music is an intriguing mix of traditional songs over very contemporary electronics. She spoke about the situation in Ukraine, including some very personal stories. I would have loved for this show to have been longer.   4. OUMOU SANGARÉ (Mali) - World Stage   The only artist on the lineup that I had seen before. The “Songbird of Wassoulou” has continued to release quality albums and I knew this was guaranteed to be good. Oumou was the final act on the main stage on Sunday; a fitting end to the festival. Her band are a mix of Mali-based and French musicians; the keyboardist stood out in particular. Oumou looks positively regal to begin with, but loosens up once she takes off her high heels. She addresses the crowd mostly in French. Sound was exceptionally good for this gig, though it has to be said it was good on the whole, with the exception of the Sunflower stage, which was a bit muddled at times.   5. FRESHLYGROUND (South Africa) - Village Stage   Freshlyground are an Afropop band from Capetown, who have been around since 2002. After seeing several performers with laptops on stage, it was a relief to see such a seasoned band with real instruments (I love the flute). The band’s long-time singer went solo in 2019, and they are now fronted by 20-year-old Mali Makhoba, an very charismatic singer who describes herself as “just a girl from the township”. This is a very uplifting gig that draws a huge crowd to the relatively small Village Stage. They finish with their hit ‘Waka Waka (This Time For Africa)’, which they recorded with Shakira on vocals for the World Cup in 2010.   6. MÁDÉ KUTI (Nigeria) - Big Top   Son of Femi Kuti, grandson of Fela Kuti. 30-year-old Mádé Kuti is a multi-instrumentalist, singer and bandleader. He has a stellar band with him, including two energetic dancers, and together they put on a fabulous show. I saw Femi Kuti on the Womad main stage a few years ago, but I have to admit I enjoyed Mádé more. He pays tribute to his father and grandfather (he covers ‘Trouble Sleep Yanga Wake Am’), takes his place amongst the brass section so that other band members can solo, and brings his reluctant wife on stage for a dance (“She hates it when I do that!”).   7. SABINE MCCALLA (USA) - Village Stage   Sabine McCalla is from New Orleans, of Haitian descent, and the sister of Leyla McCalla, who played a great set at Womad 2024. Sabine is accompanied by a guitar player and her laid-back songs are perfect for an early afternoon set in near tropical weather. “Aligators are circling round Lake Pontchartrain”… I love that line from her song ‘Baby please don’t go’.   8. ANNIE AND THE CALDWELLS (USA) - World Stage   More music from the South, this time from Mississippi. Annie Caldwell played Womad a few years ago with the Staples Junior Singers. This time she has brought her family band, with three of her daughters singing. It is a slightly slicker affair and I have to admit I thought the gospel from the older group was even better.   9. MOHAMMED REZA MORTAZAVI (Iran) - Big Top   Mohammed is a percussionist extraordinaire. He plays an entire one hour set on a Persian drum that looks not unlike a bodhrán. It is incredible how many different sounds he gets out of this single instrument, just by using his two hands. His was a late show and by that time I had been up since 5 a.m. so I was struggling against sleep a little.   10. RUST (Lebanon / Syria ) - Sunflower Tent   Rust are Petra from Lebanon and Hany from Syria. They are based in Prague and they call their music electro tarab. I like Petra’s vocals very much, but would have loved to know a bit more about the songs. Hany stands behind a deck with equipment. Many of the songs build and build and end in banging techno, which goes down well at the midnight slot they occupy. Do check out their EP ‘Masaf’.   Disappointment:   Tian Qiyi (UK).  A band of two brothers, sons of Jah Wobble. Their mother is Chinese and there is a strong Chinese influence in their music. I had listened to their album ‘Red Mist’ and had high expectations, but found them disappointing live. The guys were playing and singing live, but everything else was recorded.    Would liked to have seen: Yegor Zabelov, accordion (Belarus) Bitoi, Scandi-folk with electronica (Sweden) Lemoncello (Ireland) Stafford Campbell (UK) Yasmine Hamdan (singer from Soapkills, Lebanon)   Heard good reports from fellow volunteers about: Barrington Levy (reggae/dancehall veteran, Jamaica) Wild Wild Women (hip hop girls from Mumbai, India) Ta Dhom Project (hip hop with percussion, India)   Womad 2027 will be from 23-26 July. www.womad.co.uk for tickets.   Helen.
    • Yeah I've seen the news he's off to Arsenal and do have a lot of musings. As said, it really feels like if tapping up was something people cared about that this could have potential to be seen as such at least, but I also agree that this summer, the board have been too feeble in resisting interest in our best players and need someone better able to tell the big fish to do one like others have. It's particularly galling as it feels that Arsenal showed a lot of disrespect with the use of intermediaries to do dirty work and the first offer that was pretty much what we paid to sign Bruno from Lyon 4 1/2 years ago.   It's definitely grating as well that Bruno seemed to go all in on making out he wanted to be a hero then pretty much used some of Isak's tactics to force an exit. Which means he's probably earned boos when Arsenal come to Tyneside in November. I'm not saying that for grandstanding - players come and go and I have no doubt Arsenal are offering more money and more chances of trophies in the next 2/3 years. But the player hasn't helped himself imo.    But it is what it is. This is a pretty extreme reset and means that every decision as far as incomings goes has to be flawless. Whether I'm expecting it to be so after last year's debacle is of course another matter. At the very least the belated new manager will have a lot to do. In a way I think it's a good thing it won't be Howe trying to replace Bruno though given our record without him was so bad and the tactical choices feel like they may end up leaning into a style that worked with him had Howe stuck around. 
    • Weezer just announced a May tour so that's them ruled out.
    • Blimey, I thought it wasn’t going as well due to the pricing and as it didn’t fly out ticket sale day.    Incredible that people are paying it, not had a good album in about 20 years now. Quite disappointing at those prices as it’ll keep climbing if people keep paying unfortunately. 
  • Featured Products

  • Hot Topics

  • Latest Tourdates

×
×
  • Create New...