No, at the very beginning I singled those three out as looking somewhat anachronistic, which is what started this whole convo. (Btw, the third was sheryl crow, not kylie - who I have already said is clearly a great booking.)
Your second point I largely agree with, which is where I’m kind of struggling with all this. While in principle I like the idea, in practice I don’t actually want to go and watch acts such as these three at all (or pay money for avPrimavera ticket, which I was v much considering before the line up came out).
Therefore, after a bit of debate here, I asked if anyone who was supporting their bookings actually wanted to go and see all three (wouldn’t have made much sense for me to ask about three acts, such as kylie, who I think personally are good bookings). I personally think it’s not great if they are booking anachronistic acts like JJ right at thr top of the bill for the ‘wrong’ reasons - especially if no one actually wants to go and see them .
We are never going to know the reasons for her booking though are we, so I’m more than happy to leave this where it is now, as has been suggested. The end.