Who did you go for in the end? I was in a very similar position. I love Elton, and assumed I’d be there, but couldn’t get QOTSA out of my head all weekend. Decided I’d get more out of QOTSA live than Elton and make a night of it one day this week watching him on TV. Ecstatic with my decision, managed to get on the barrier and the field with full of hard core fans. Easily my set of the weekend.