Jump to content

Don't Miss a Beat

Join the UK's most passionate festival community. Keep up with the latest conversations, line-up rumours, and music news.

250,000+ Members

Connect with a massive network of fellow festival-goers.

Lively Discussions

Thousands of active topics on music, campsites, and tips.

Hot Rumours & News

Hear about secret sets and lineup drops before anyone else.

Create Free Account
OR
  • Sign Up!

    Join our friendly community of music lovers and be part of the fun 😎

World Cup 2010


Guest Cardboard Box City

Recommended Posts

Oh c'mon ... while a week ago I wouldn't have much cared, it just wouldn't be right for Uruguay to make the final seeing as they only made the semi via blatant cheating. If cheats are seen to prosper, then cheating will become even more the norm than it is already.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 3.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Oh c'mon ... while a week ago I wouldn't have much cared, it just wouldn't be right for Uruguay to make the final seeing as they only made the semi via blatant cheating. If cheats are seen to prosper, then cheating will become even more the norm than it is already.

Edited by ralph250
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh c'mon ... while a week ago I wouldn't have much cared, it just wouldn't be right for Uruguay to make the final seeing as they only made the semi via blatant cheating. If cheats are seen to prosper, then cheating will become even more the norm than it is already.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Admin

exactly.

with uruguay, it wasn't a blatant attempt at conning the ref or anything. it was natural reaction that was punished. and fortunately for them, ghana didn't take the chance to fully punish them. and paid for it.

"gamesmanship" is not Fair Play. Is football about Fair Play, or is it about doing whatever it takes to win?

If it's about winning at all costs, then forget about Fair Play, forget about what football was, cheer when your team breaks the leg of any opponent, and admire the cheats over the ball players. ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"gamesmanship" is not Fair Play. Is football about Fair Play, or is it about doing whatever it takes to win?

If it's about winning at all costs, then forget about Fair Play, forget about what football was, cheer when your team breaks the leg of any opponent, and admire the cheats over the ball players. ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'd love to see the Dutch do well. Over the years they've given us absolutely great footballers that have thrilled me utterly.

Uruguay have given us Danielle Fonsecca.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"gamesmanship" is not Fair Play. Is football about Fair Play, or is it about doing whatever it takes to win?

If it's about winning at all costs, then forget about Fair Play, forget about what football was, cheer when your team breaks the leg of any opponent, and admire the cheats over the ball players. ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Quite frankly that's bollocks. If football (or any sport ever) were about Fair Play, there wouldn't be any need for a referee.

Thinking about it, isn't there a team sport that doesn't have a referee... ultimate frisbee or something?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

good point, well made!

and football is about both. if you don't want to win, get the f**k off the pitch. i'd hate football if it was just about fair play. why bother keeping scores at all? as long as everyone tried their best and had fun! ^_^

Edited by ralph250
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Admin

he instinctively stopped the ball crossing the line. he never broke anyones legs. he was punished, it wasn't his fault gyan shat his pants in the spotlight.

He cheated to stop what would otherwise have been a fair goal (on the basis that the ball was still in play).

I seem to remember extremely loud shouts from you of "CHEAT" against Henry, yet it wasn't Henry's (instinctive or not) handball that caused the ball to go into the Irish net. ;)

It might have been instinctive or it might not have been - only one person knows the answer to that one. But that aside, this is an instance where the punishment doesn't fit the crime, so while the rules say that's how it works it can hardly be regarded as fair in any shape or form.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He cheated to stop what would otherwise have been a fair goal (on the basis that the ball was still in play).

I seem to remember extremely loud shouts from you of "CHEAT" against Henry, yet it wasn't Henry's (instinctive or not) handball that caused the ball to go into the Irish net. ;)

It might have been instinctive or it might not have been - only one person knows the answer to that one. But that aside, this is an instance where the punishment doesn't fit the crime, so while the rules say that's how it works it can hardly be regarded as fair in any shape or form.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Admin

Quite frankly that's bollocks. If football (or any sport ever) were about Fair Play, there wouldn't be any need for a referee.

That's simply not true.

Some offences or calls are clear, but others are not and need a 3rd party to decide which way it should go - for example, where a ball bounces on the legs of opposing players several times before going out of play, or where there's a fierce tackle that may or may not have been a foul.

There was a time when the ref had to make the call far less than they do now, and not so long ago either. For example, nowadays it's rare for the ball to go out for a throw-in without both sides claiming the opponent had the last touch with one side knowing they're trying to cheat, yet that used to happen far far less than it does now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not justifying it but slightly differentiated from Henry.

Henry's was 103rd minute so Ireland still had opportunity to score (and would've progressed on away goals if they had), and equally had France not scored via Henry's handball then France would still be in with an opportunity via penalties (as tied on away goals).

Uruguay were out, it was last kick of the game. It was last chance saloon and so instinct might've kicked in more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Admin

Teams for years have used the rules to their own team's advantage.

Foul play is now an allowable part of the rules, is it? :lol::lol::lol:

...As I said, I don't agree with what Suarez did, but equally would expect any player to do the same in the 120th min at a world cup quarter final, and part of me is sypathetic to the fact that he's gonna miss a semi (and possibly a final if they do extend the ban) when play shouldn't have gone that far if the officials made the right calls. Equally as discussed, he didn't get away with it a la Henry. He was sent off and penalty given.

That's laughable, and about as pathetic as it gets.

"Getting away with it" is the result of any cheating, not whether it's spotted or not. :rolleyes:

When a prem player foul-tackles your beloved Rooney and breaks his leg, do you say "it's alright, the ref spotted it was a foul and gave us a free kick. It's all fair".

As I said, laughable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Admin

Neither would that "goal" be on Uruguay if it had gone in. As above, probable dive to win it and offside.

Yep, but offside is one of those things which regularly called wrongly (in both directions) - it's an unavoidable aspect of the game. For discussion of that handball, it's an irrelevance - the offside wasn't called and so the ball was still in play.

If handling on the line is now to be considered as somehow acceptable, I suggest that all the teams tipped for the drop don't bother trying to play any match, and instead just line-up 10 players on the goal line, and play the goalie in front of them. A guaranteed 36 points, and relegation is avoided.

That's ultimately what you're advocating. That really would be 'the beautiful game'. :lol::lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Latest Activity

    • Very nice to read your review.  Here's mine.  I enjoyed it all so much that I bought a pre-sale ticket for 2027!   ____   WOMAD FESTIVAL 23-26 July 2026  Neston Park, Corsham, Wiltshere   Womad is back! The festival took a year off last year to recalibrate. They were moving to a new location, and no doubt the fact that so many festivals have ceased to exist as a result of financial problems in the current climate made it important for Womad to get things right going forward. And did they! The festival was a resounding success. Sold out, with brilliant music and smiling faces all around.    From 2007 until 2024 the festival was held at Charlton Park in Wiltshere. I went there six times.  Sometimes the festival clashed wth Cambridge Folk Festival, but since the pandemic I have found myself preferring Womad. It offers greater diversity. There are acts from all over the world and I feel I can trust the organisers to come up with stuff I will enjoy.    The new site is a beauty. Neston Park is an estate near Corsham.  Melksham is the nearest train station; Bath the nearest bigger town. The Real World studios are nearby in the village of Box. The weather was again very warm and the site thankfully has many shaded areas with trees. The camping fields offer enough space that people do not need to camp on top of each other. There are four main stages and best of all, programming is such that there was never any sound overspill. Toilets were mostly of the compost variety. The food I sampled was delicious, albeit expensive, and they had very nice Clear Head alcohol-free beer on tap, which predictably ran out on Saturday.    I went as an Oxfam volunteer, which benefits a good cause and was enjoyable as ever, but I have to admit that it was killing me how much I was missing that I wanted to be at, due to having to work. I was not able to participate in the many interesting workshops and presentations on offer. I am planning to go as a punter next year, and volunteer elsewhere where the lineup is less crucial. My shifts were in the camping fields. This was relatively easy due to the Womad festival goers being very well behaved (“You can’t go that way“; “Oh, I see”). I enjoyed spending time up on the fire tower, from where the view was great.   Peter Gabriel made an appearance at the World of Words stage. Lopa Kothari was on compere duty on the World Stage (the main stage), and for me a most welcome addition was Justin Adams compering the second stage - the Big Top. Justin is a fantastic guitarist who has collaborated with and produced many world music greats (Robert Plant, Tinariwen, Souad Massi, Sharon Shannon). Justin is so knowledgeable and enthusiastic, it was a real joy to have him in the Big Top all weekend, and I liked his unshouty style of presenting.   These were my musical highlights:   1. GANAVYA (India) - Big Top   Singer Ganavya is from New York, of Indian heritage, and she spent many years living in Tamil Nadu. The first striking thing when she walks onstage is how pregnant she is. She explains she is eight months. At times it looked like there might be a Womad baby. Ganavya is accompanied by a harpist and a cellist. Stunning music and great storytelling too. She is a graduate from Berklee College of Music and has worked as a teacher as well, which is evident from her engaging talk. She reminded me of Arooj Aftab, mostly because of her dry and self-deprecating sense of humour. Her show ended with a wonderful singalong traditional, the high point of the entire festival for me. I will certainly seek her music out further.   2. SEPPUKU PISTOLS (Japan) - World Stage   The Seppuku Pistols are an anarchist punk group with traditional instruments. There’s thirteen of them, different ages. They started in the middle of the crowd and then made their way over to the stage. Many of the members play percussion. The leader is an older guy, who spoke at length and with great conviction in Japanese, before yelling “translate!” to a band member. There was so much going on, sometimes you didn’t know where to look. I was near the front, but band members frequently went with instruments and all into the moshpit. At the same time someone could come crowdsurfing overhead. Apparently one of them broke his ankle, didn’t realise and finished the gig. “I think you all need to go and decompress”, Lopa Kothari said to the audience once it was over. Everybody left the main stage with big smiles, shaking their heads.   3. GANNA (Ukraine) - Sunflower Tent   Ganna is a Ukrainian singer, based in Berlin. She performs solo, standing behind a table with equipment. This is never my favourite set-up, however her voice, songs, stage presence and stories were so remarkable that I can get over the lack of a proper band. My shift partner saw her at the ‘Taste the World’ stage and told me she is equally good without the box of tricks. Her singing is not unlike Sámi joiking. Ganna’s singing was so impressive that everyone (finally!) stopped talking. Her music is an intriguing mix of traditional songs over very contemporary electronics. She spoke about the situation in Ukraine, including some very personal stories. I would have loved for this show to have been longer.   4. OUMOU SANGARÉ (Mali) - World Stage   The only artist on the lineup that I had seen before. The “Songbird of Wassoulou” has continued to release quality albums and I knew this was guaranteed to be good. Oumou was the final act on the main stage on Sunday; a fitting end to the festival. Her band are a mix of Mali-based and French musicians; the keyboardist stood out in particular. Oumou looks positively regal to begin with, but loosens up once she takes off her high heels. She addresses the crowd mostly in French. Sound was exceptionally good for this gig, though it has to be said it was good on the whole, with the exception of the Sunflower stage, which was a bit muddled at times.   5. FRESHLYGROUND (South Africa) - Village Stage   Freshlyground are an Afropop band from Capetown, who have been around since 2002. After seeing several performers with laptops on stage, it was a relief to see such a seasoned band with real instruments (I love the flute). The band’s long-time singer went solo in 2019, and they are now fronted by 20-year-old Mali Makhoba, an very charismatic singer who describes herself as “just a girl from the township”. This is a very uplifting gig that draws a huge crowd to the relatively small Village Stage. They finish with their hit ‘Waka Waka (This Time For Africa)’, which they recorded with Shakira on vocals for the World Cup in 2010.   6. MÁDÉ KUTI (Nigeria) - Big Top   Son of Femi Kuti, grandson of Fela Kuti. 30-year-old Mádé Kuti is a multi-instrumentalist, singer and bandleader. He has a stellar band with him, including two energetic dancers, and together they put on a fabulous show. I saw Femi Kuti on the Womad main stage a few years ago, but I have to admit I enjoyed Mádé more. He pays tribute to his father and grandfather (he covers ‘Trouble Sleep Yanga Wake Am’), takes his place amongst the brass section so that other band members can solo, and brings his reluctant wife on stage for a dance (“She hates it when I do that!”).   7. SABINE MCCALLA (USA) - Village Stage   Sabine McCalla is from New Orleans, of Haitian descent, and the sister of Leyla McCalla, who played a great set at Womad 2024. Sabine is accompanied by a guitar player and her laid-back songs are perfect for an early afternoon set in near tropical weather. “Aligators are circling round Lake Pontchartrain”… I love that line from her song ‘Baby please don’t go’.   8. ANNIE AND THE CALDWELLS (USA) - World Stage   More music from the South, this time from Mississippi. Annie Caldwell played Womad a few years ago with the Staples Junior Singers. This time she has brought her family band, with three of her daughters singing. It is a slightly slicker affair and I have to admit I thought the gospel from the older group was even better.   9. MOHAMMED REZA MORTAZAVI (Iran) - Big Top   Mohammed is a percussionist extraordinaire. He plays an entire one hour set on a Persian drum that looks not unlike a bodhrán. It is incredible how many different sounds he gets out of this single instrument, just by using his two hands. His was a late show and by that time I had been up since 5 a.m. so I was struggling against sleep a little.   10. RUST (Lebanon / Syria ) - Sunflower Tent   Rust are Petra from Lebanon and Hany from Syria. They are based in Prague and they call their music electro tarab. I like Petra’s vocals very much, but would have loved to know a bit more about the songs. Hany stands behind a deck with equipment. Many of the songs build and build and end in banging techno, which goes down well at the midnight slot they occupy. Do check out their EP ‘Masaf’.   Disappointment:   Tian Qiyi (UK).  A band of two brothers, sons of Jah Wobble. Their mother is Chinese and there is a strong Chinese influence in their music. I had listened to their album ‘Red Mist’ and had high expectations, but found them disappointing live. The guys were playing and singing live, but everything else was recorded.    Would liked to have seen: Yegor Zabelov, accordion (Belarus) Bitoi, Scandi-folk with electronica (Sweden) Lemoncello (Ireland) Stafford Campbell (UK) Yasmine Hamdan (singer from Soapkills, Lebanon)   Heard good reports from fellow volunteers about: Barrington Levy (reggae/dancehall veteran, Jamaica) Wild Wild Women (hip hop girls from Mumbai, India) Ta Dhom Project (hip hop with percussion, India)   Womad 2027 will be from 23-26 July. www.womad.co.uk for tickets.   Helen.
    • Yeah I've seen the news he's off to Arsenal and do have a lot of musings. As said, it really feels like if tapping up was something people cared about that this could have potential to be seen as such at least, but I also agree that this summer, the board have been too feeble in resisting interest in our best players and need someone better able to tell the big fish to do one like others have. It's particularly galling as it feels that Arsenal showed a lot of disrespect with the use of intermediaries to do dirty work and the first offer that was pretty much what we paid to sign Bruno from Lyon 4 1/2 years ago.   It's definitely grating as well that Bruno seemed to go all in on making out he wanted to be a hero then pretty much used some of Isak's tactics to force an exit. Which means he's probably earned boos when Arsenal come to Tyneside in November. I'm not saying that for grandstanding - players come and go and I have no doubt Arsenal are offering more money and more chances of trophies in the next 2/3 years. But the player hasn't helped himself imo.    But it is what it is. This is a pretty extreme reset and means that every decision as far as incomings goes has to be flawless. Whether I'm expecting it to be so after last year's debacle is of course another matter. At the very least the belated new manager will have a lot to do. In a way I think it's a good thing it won't be Howe trying to replace Bruno though given our record without him was so bad and the tactical choices feel like they may end up leaning into a style that worked with him had Howe stuck around. 
    • Weezer just announced a May tour so that's them ruled out.
    • Blimey, I thought it wasn’t going as well due to the pricing and as it didn’t fly out ticket sale day.    Incredible that people are paying it, not had a good album in about 20 years now. Quite disappointing at those prices as it’ll keep climbing if people keep paying unfortunately. 
  • Featured Products

  • Hot Topics

  • Latest Tourdates

×
×
  • Create New...