If you love Interpol, your post-Antics comment is weird. I can give you ten songs without thinking that would be brilliant in any set. I acknowledge their first three albums are the best and TOTBL is the greatest album ever 😉
Pioneer
Heinrich
Lights
All The Rage
Toni
If You Really Love Nothing
Rest my Chemistry
The Lighthouse
Barricade
Mammoth
I could name more off the most recent albums but I'd have to check song names.
Forgot No I in Threesome too.