Jump to content

Your most controversial music opinions


CaledonianGonzo
 Share

Recommended Posts

4 minutes ago, Florian Saucer Attack said:

@CaledonianGonzo and @priest17 you are both wrong.

Both punk and disco are great and revolutionary in their own ways.

I hope one day you both broaden your horizons and realise this as the world will be a more magical place 

No.  I said there were exceptions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No problem with people slagging off a musical genre they don't like. But I don't like the inference that all punks were walking around wearing swastikas. None of the punk kids that I hung around with would have dreamed of it and would have got a slap if they had. We didn't all grow up to be Gary Bushell!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, CaledonianGonzo said:

It's still going strong though and - as progenitor of house,techno and hip hop - it's unarguably part of the lineage of African-American music that continues to shape both the current and most forward-looking ways of making music.

Punk gave us Idles.

 

Although I do tip my hat to any punk fans who made it through Idles' bit of Live On Worthy Farm without spontaneously combusting out of embarrassment.

We can join together wincing at idles cringey nature, at least it got an actual reaction from us. Disco has limped along, picked up randomly by pop acts out if ideas (even, sadly, Daft Punk). 

I see decent, raw, upcoming acts perform every week. Funny how you don't see anyone in their late teens/early 20s limp through a disco set it's for boring oldies.

 

There are no exceptions. My horizons are perfectly broad. I am right.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Punksnotdead said:

No problem with people slagging off a musical genre they don't like. But I don't like the inference that all punks were walking around wearing swastikas. None of the punk kids that I hung around with would have dreamed of it and would have got a slap if they had. We didn't all grow up to be Gary Bushell!

No worries dude. I'm aware of Crass.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, Florian Saucer Attack said:

@CaledonianGonzo and @priest17 you are both wrong.

Both punk and disco are great and revolutionary in their own ways.

I hope one day you both broaden your horizons and realise this as the world will be a more magical place 

sshhhh - just sit back and watch the ding dong. What the tread is about 🙂 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 minutes ago, priest17 said:

Punk was born out of people who couldn't play instruments picking them up and fucking doing something. The DIY scene it created went on to have a massive impact on the dance and rave scene. Imagine being talented and deciding to play... Disco? Better than dressing up as a wizard and doing a 10 minute keyboard solo to be fair.

Is this why all the bands you post in the new music thread are shite and sound the same 😂😂😂

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, CaledonianGonzo said:

Ca Plane Pour Moi by Plastic Betrand.

When I was but a child, my sister had a party in our house that included a bunch of French exchange students. They all went mental to this, including one who pogo'd into my mother's very fashionable ceiling lights and nearly knocked himself out.

I will forever love that song just for the memory of that but it is indeed a banger.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Gnomicide said:

When I was but a child, my sister had a party in our house that included a bunch of French exchange students. They all went mental to this, including one who pogo'd into my mother's very fashionable ceiling lights and nearly knocked himself out.

I will forever love that song just for the memory of that but it is indeed a banger.

True story:  I had to write a French language profile of Plastic Bertrand as part of my French Standard Grade exam.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, priest17 said:

We can join together wincing at idles cringey nature, at least it got an actual reaction from us. Disco has limped along, picked up randomly by pop acts out if ideas (even, sadly, Daft Punk). 

I see decent, raw, upcoming acts perform every week. Funny how you don't see anyone in their late teens/early 20s limp through a disco set it's for boring oldies.

 

There are no exceptions. My horizons are perfectly broad. I am right.

Some of the best, most exciting sets from DJs I’ve seen over the last few years are disco ones. Certainly plenty of exciting stuff in the genre and it’s loved by so many people around my age in their twenties and definitely isn’t for oldies. 

More Brewdog swigging old people watching a set by the latest AF gang approved punk band with a one word name in all caps.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Mouseboy11 said:

Some of the best, most exciting sets from DJs I’ve seen over the last few years are disco ones. Certainly plenty of exciting stuff in the genre and it’s loved by so many people around my age in their twenties and definitely isn’t for oldies. 

More Brewdog swigging old people watching a set by the latest AF gang approved punk band with a one word name in all caps.

Pretty sure I saw you stood around a table screaming Danny Nedelko at Sadanista once.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, CaledonianGonzo said:

Ca Plane Pour Moi by Plastic Betrand.

If you like that then you will love circle jerks, black flag, the germs, swans, teenage jesus and the jerks to name but a few.

You just need to go in with an open mind.

I think you should spend all weekend locked in your room listening to a 100 punk albums and @priest17 will do the same with disco. You'll both never be the same again 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 hours ago, Kurczak said:

Pink Floyd- I don't need that plod and echo

Sex Pistols at the time were a band for 14 yr olds, just childish shite (apart from bodies), nazi punks can fuck off, sid was a murderer. At the time Joy Division were also in the poop over their nazi name too, and I love the Skids!!

There is no excuse for John Peel, it was never a good thing

Prog rock ffs.

PiL is the best band ever.

Trout Mask Replica is Beefheart's worst album, people only pretend to like it.

Jazz should only be used as a punishment. 

You are @hfuhruhurr and I claim my ten pounds. Either that or shameless plagiarism to get a reaction.

 

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Florian Saucer Attack said:

If you like that then you will love circle jerks, black flag, the germs, swans, teenage jesus and the jerks to name but a few.

You just need to go in with an open mind.

I think you should spend all weekend locked in your room listening to a 100 punk albums and @priest17 will do the same with disco. You'll both never be the same again 

Is this the world's first Plastic Bertrand / Michael Gira comparison?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Latest Activity

    • We’re after 1 Oxfam spot for my wife, having secured one myself back in Feb.   We’ve been weighing up whether to stick or twist with the cutoff coming up.    Your words sound encouraging though so we might have to stick it out and hammer the Oxfam site for that 1 spot! 
    • This gives us hope! We're lucky enough to work on our laptops all day so this is all possible!
    • So long as you requested your bus via the transport survey before April 15th, you're all good - there haven't been any confirmation emails yet 
    • Did some digging online. Well, you did ask.   There isn't much there that's very recent. An application for planning permission for "use of land for siting of up to 16 low impact residential shelters within a woodland garden setting and associated operational development comprising car park, telephone box, and children's play structure" was rejected in 1999 - though apparently there was a "legal breakthrough" in 2001. This is from 1995:   Clearly it's still in use. A resident called Theo Simon stood for election to the local council (for the Green Party) in 2017. His band, Seize the Day, seems to play Glastonbury every year (at Toad Hall, Small World, sometimes other sets elsewhere). This is a video of their 2019 set:     There's an interview with him, probably filmed at Kings Hill, here. He sounds pretty cool if you ask me.   https://www.futurelearn.com/info/courses/why-religion-matters/0/steps/73899   This is from a university thesis submitted in 1999:   The King’s Hill Collective The King’s Hill Collective can be seen as solution to increasing pressures of living on the road for Travellers who were bringing up children and as a solution to (and rejection of) mainstream consumerist society by non Travellers many of whom were originally city dwellers. Nevertheless because many of the members had direct travelling experience, this community provided an example of one extreme in a continuum between those Travellers for whom the tag ‘New Age’ is a complete irrelevance and those for whom it is at least understandable if not desirable. This group is on the ‘New Age’, ecologically aware, ideologically ‘hippie’ and ‘sorted’ end of the New Age Traveller continuum discussed in the previous chapter. The site, which overlooks Pilton farm (the site of the Glastonbury Festival), is slowly maturing now with numerous trees, vegetables and a fully functioning water bore hole which supplies the site with drinking water. Water is extracted on a weekly basis using an old petrol engine and pump. The water, which is filtered by a series of sand traps, is inspected on an annual basis. The collective is concerned to demonstrate its willingness to 243adhere to regulations were this is possible and not contrary to its collective ideology. There are 16 plots, each at some stage of the development of the site, having a bender.   The benders are almost exclusively constructed of light green Tarpaulin over a hazel wood matrix. Stainless steel flexi-vents lead from stoves in the benders. These act as chimneys supported by a single branch driven into the earth. The stoves are usually home-made conversions of gas cylinders which have been cut and welded into shape although there was an solid fuel Rayburn installed in one bender during the study period. Inside the benders bedding is arranged on wooden pallets or platforms and there is often an additional gas stove for cooking. Water is supplied either directly from the holding tank or stored in water barrels. Lighting is almost exclusively by candles or ‘hurricane lamps’. Twelve volt batteries and in one case a wind generator supplies electricity for radios and in one case a small black and white television. Some of the more established benders had a variety of trees and shrubs around the canvass construction including apple, pear and fig trees as well as a variety of fruits.   The collective is serviced by a pay telephone located in an old red telephone box. Its position, in the middle of a field, is as incongruous as the lamp post in C.S. Lewis’s Narnia books and is in a way reminiscent of the TARDIS of Doctor Who, adding to the slightly surreal or magical atmosphere of the place. Inside a small domestic pay phone is installed and managed by one of the community.   At the centre of the site is a clearing of grass that acts as a communal area surrounded by a small circular mound inside of which runs a circular ditch in the fashion of a place of worship. In the centre of the circle is a small collection of sea stones collected from a nearby shoreline. There are four gaps in the mound representing the solstices and equinoxes, which correspond to the cardinal points of the compass. Each section of the mound was constructed during the period of the year that it represents. There are symbols representing Beltane and other significant calendar dates placed appropriately on the circle. The King’s Hill site owes its existence to Chris Black, a man who was broadly sympathetic to alternative lifestyles and provided initial financial support to the project. Chris Black purchased the field and ‘loaned’ sixteen plots to a number of Travellers and bender dwellers. The newly formed community developed a ‘constitution’ and organised a system whereby the loan of the plots was paid back over a period of two years through weekly contributions to a central fund. Thus after two years the land belonged to sixteen stakeholders.
    • K.O.G. were one of my favourite acts at EOTR a couple of years ago. Just a joyful afrobeat danceathon
  • Featured Products

  • Hot Topics

  • Latest Tourdates

×
×
  • Create New...