55 replies to this topic

[rexclark]

So if you like rock you can't like Lady Gaga?

What a load of pish, people really need to realise that some people like more than one type of music.

I quite like Lady Gaga but there's no way she'd ever get on the R&L line up, it'd be like Daphne and Celeste all over again.

[cheeseisamazing]

sjp_121, on Mar 17 2010, 05:40 PM, said:

and hate Oasis.

Isnt that a crime in our country?

[Lewis2804]

This thread should just be deleted lmao

[cheeseisamazing]

lidds, on Mar 17 2010, 06:00 PM, said:

simply seeing this thread in the reading and leeds forum makes me feel sick

free speech, terrible. makes me feel sick
someone having a opinion thats differnt to mine urghh, its terrible
jokes


tbh mate. if i'd put JLS, cherly cole, spice girls i'd agree. but the fact that gaga writes all her own songs, can atualy play lots of insturments and can atualy sing...  i appreciate that she writes pop music and is a glorified pop icon, but give her some credit.

besides, i would

[Role Model]

rexclark, on Mar 17 2010, 09:34 PM, said:

So if you like rock you can't like Lady Gaga?

What a load of pish, people really need to realise that some people like more than one type of music.

I quite like Lady Gaga but there's no way she'd ever get on the R&L line up, it'd be like Daphne and Celeste all over again.

nope i just dont think it would, not these days, and certainly not if she headlined the nme tent or something.

[adam1234]

cheeseisamazing, on Mar 17 2010, 07:41 PM, said:

free speech, terrible. makes me feel sick
someone having a opinion thats differnt to mine urghh, its terrible
jokes


tbh mate. if i'd put JLS, cherly cole, spice girls i'd agree. but the fact that gaga writes all her own songs, can atualy play lots of insturments and can atualy sing...  i appreciate that she writes pop music and is a glorified pop icon, but give her some credit.

besides, i would

Hahaha now were getting down to the real reason you want her there.

[rexclark]

Role Model, on Mar 17 2010, 07:45 PM, said:

nope i just dont think it would, not these days, and certainly not if she headlined the nme tent or something.

All depends on where you stick her, but you will always get a few arseholes thinking "she doesn't belong here" and chucking bottles.

This thread just proves this fact.

Edited by rexclark, 17 March 2010 - 07:57 PM.

[Role Model]

true, you're not wrong there.

[Sam Lanham]

cheeseisamazing, on Mar 17 2010, 07:34 PM, said:

Isnt that a crime in our country?

If so I'm guilty.

[craigb]

What about alicia keys? Less pop and more rnb/soul, would she go down well?
She may not have the "wow" factor of beyonce and gaga but prob more musically talented than both.
I have seen beyonce with jay-z, alicia keys and seeing gaga this year. With beyonce and gaga is all about the show at their concerts whereas alicia keys is all about the music

[cheeseisamazing]

craigb, on Mar 17 2010, 08:37 PM, said:

What about alicia keys? Less pop and more rnb/soul, would she go down well?
She may not have the "wow" factor of beyonce and gaga but prob more musically talented than both.
I have seen beyonce with jay-z, alicia keys and seeing gaga this year. With beyonce and gaga is all about the show at their concerts whereas alicia keys is all about the music

you may have razed a point abut the flood gates....

[MJMilz14]

kev1664, on Mar 17 2010, 03:57 PM, said:

How do I have a snobbish opinion? Lady gaga is pop, full scale no two ways about it pop. R&L is an 'alternative' festival, where pop has no place

Stopped reading here.

Lady Gaga probably doesn't belong at Reading as such, but there's nothing wrong at all with having a few different kinds of acts placed sparringly across the weekend. It's when the whole lineup is dominated by it, it becomes a problem.

Gaga would look bloody odd on the lineup, but id sure as hell go and see her.

[kev1664]

cheeseisamazing, on Mar 17 2010, 07:41 PM, said:

free speech, terrible. makes me feel sick
someone having a opinion thats differnt to mine urghh, its terrible
jokes


tbh mate. if i'd put JLS, cherly cole, spice girls i'd agree. but the fact that gaga writes all her own songs, can atualy play lots of insturments and can atualy sing...  i appreciate that she writes pop music and is a glorified pop icon, but give her some credit.

besides, i would

lol as rumours would have it she's a bit well endowed for a girl
Or is that why you would?

cheeseisamazing, on Mar 17 2010, 10:46 PM, said:

you may have razed a point abut the flood gates....

Told you what would happen, let one big mainstream pop act play and it'll just escalates out of hand, and thats just on the forum, imagine at the festival.

Lets just stop this right here, right now! lol.

Edited by kev1664, 17 March 2010 - 11:43 PM.

[MJMilz14]

kev1664, on Mar 17 2010, 11:41 PM, said:

lol as rumours would have it she's a bit well endowed for a girl
Or is that why you would?

There's a key word hidden right there in your post.

[gr4h4m]

I'm not afraid to say I really like her music and that she would be a welcome addition to the line up, she's sold loads of records, been in the top 10 for ages, had numerous number one singles, won aload of awards at the Brits. To befair she'd actually be big enough now to headline

[pigshair123]

GUNS!
RAZORS!
KNIVES!